Renters Are Staying Put

It’s no secret that homeownership is getting more expensive by the day. With mortgage rates hovering around 7%+, would-be buyers are hitting pause on the American Dream, opting instead to stay in place… and rent a little longer. This shift isn’t just a blip on the radar, it’s a signal multifamily investors need to pay attention to.

‍

So, what’s going on?

‍

The “Lock-In Effect” Explained

The lock-in effect refers to the growing number of homeowners, and would-be buyers, who are delaying moves due to financial pressure. Homeowners who locked in 2-3% mortgage rates during 2020-2021 aren’t eager to swap that for today’s rates. And first-time buyers? They’re facing brutal affordability challenges thanks to higher monthly payments, limited inventory, and sticky inflation.

As a result, many potential buyers are staying on the sidelines; in their rental units.

‍

What This Means for Multifamily Operators

This trend is driving some notable outcomes:

• Increased Retention Rates: Tenants who might have otherwise transitioned to homeownership are choosing to renew leases instead.
  
  
• Reduced Turnover Costs: With fewer move-outs, operators are spending less on unit turns, marketing, and leasing commissions.
  
  
• Stronger Predictability: Longer tenancy allows for more stable cash flow and planning, especially in a market where rent growth is flattening.
  
  

In short, the lock-in effect is helping investors defend occupancy and NOI, even as rent growth cools and operating expenses stay elevated.

‍

Strategic Implications for Investors

Here’s how multifamily syndicators can capitalize:

• Double Down on Renewals: Prioritize lease renewal incentives and resident engagement strategies to keep turnover low.
  
  
• Focus on Affordability: Middle-income and workforce housing are especially well-positioned to benefit from this trend. People still need a place to live and many can’t afford to buy.
  
  
• Upgrade Without Overdoing It: Class B/C assets with smart renovations offer the best balance for cost-conscious renters seeking better living without breaking the bank.
  

‍

The Big Picture

While rising interest rates have made acquisitions trickier, they’re also reinforcing the long-term strength of the rental market. Multifamily remains a critical solution in a housing system that simply isn’t delivering enough for-sale product at affordable prices.

As always, the key is adaptability. Investors who lean into data, resident trends, and operational efficiency will be best positioned to thrive in this “new normal.”

‍

Final Thought
The path to homeownership may be on hold for millions of Americans, but for multifamily investors, that pause is creating a moment of opportunity. Stay tuned in, stay nimble, and make the most of where the market is headed, not just where it’s been.

‍

Disclaimer: The information provided is for educational purposes only and should not be considered as advice. Always consult with a qualified professional before making any financial decisions.